Saturday, September 13, 2008

Press release by Lawyer Mark W. Benjamin on appeal of bar "Theater Night" conviction.

Formal appeal http://presslord.com/cigap.html

MARK W. BENJAMIN
Criminal Defense, P.A.
237 Second Avenue SW, Suite 111
Cambridge, MN 55008
763-691-0900 (office)
763-670-9664 (mobile)


PressRelease

Mark Benjamin files appellatebrief with the MN Court of Appeals to overturn conviction of his bar owner clientwho hosted Theater Night in his bar and allowing his patrons to smoke indoors.
On Friday, September 12, 2008, criminaldefense attorney Mark W. Benjamin filed his appellate brief with the MinnesotaCourt of Appeals to overturn the petty misdemeanor conviction of his client TomMarinaro.

Mr. Marinaro is the owner of Tank’sBar in Babbitt, Minnesota. On March 14,2008, he was issued a citation for allowing his patrons to smoke indoors duringhis theatrical production of “The Gunsmoke Monologues”. Mr. Marinaro pled not guilty and demanded acourt trial, arguing that he and his patrons were engaged in a legal activity, namely,the production and performance of an improvisational play.

His play called attention to lossof individual liberties, governmental intrusion into private business and theeconomic devastation wrought by the state-wide smoking ban. His play also allowed smoking by designated actors and actresses who wished to participate in his play.
Minnesota’s state-wide smokingban took effect on October 1, 2007. It included an exception (inserted during the closing days of the legislativesession) that allowed actors and actresses to smoke as part of a “theatricalperformance”. Short of requiring advance notice to patrons that there might be some smoking during a play, the legislature failed to limit who could put on a theatrical production, orwhether the production required a stage, costumes or scripts.

Minnesota bar owners beganhosting Theater Nights in February 2008 and reported that their revenues – even in a recession economy – jumped back to pre-ban levels virtuallyovernight. Smoking ban advocates whined that Theater Night was a loophole. Bar owners said it a lifeline.

Mr. Marinaro went to court on May23, 2008, was found guilty and issued the maximum fine of $300.

Mr. Benjamin’s appeal makes thefollowing points:

The police chief was pressured by a city councilor to issue Mr. Marinaro a ticket, even though the chief himself wasn’t sure Mr. Marinaro was breaking the law.

The trial judge thought it “absurd” to consider Mr. Marinaro’s production to be a real play because it didn’t have any costumes or scripts and wasn’t performed on a stage.

But a 1970 U.S. Supreme Court case stated that theatrical productions didn’t have to be performed on a stage by professional actors, or be heavily financed or elaborately produced.
When the legislature slipped the “theatrical productions” exception into the smoking ban bill at the last minute, it did so as a favor to the Guthrie Theater.

When a legislator pointed out that that bar owners might use the “theatrical productions” exception to host their own plays and smoke indoors, the other legislators laughed, instead of tightening up the language. Now they want the courts to clean up their mess.

The language of the exception is clear and unambiguous. Smoking during theatrical productions is a legal activity. With no standards provided by the legislature, no cop or court has the authority to judge what is good or bad theater.

Even so, the Minnesota Department of Health still believes smoking during a theatrical production in a bar is illegal because … it’s in a bar.

A reply brief will be filed in 45days. Oral arguments at the Court ofAppeals in St. Paul will take place at a later date.

Attached is a copy of Mr.Benjamin’s brief. http://presslord.com/cigap.html
Our show goes on.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Star Tribune MN smoking survey and my "redrant"

First the story link. I tried to post in the comments section but I kept getting a "cannot connect" message. http://www.startribune.com/lifestyle/health/28119824.html?page=1&c=y

Here is my posting aka "redrant". I don't doubt a drop overall but I would have to see the details of the survey.

As for the overall state rate there was a strong demographic attrition of the "greatest generation" that fought in WWII. Let's say the typical WWII vet was born in 1920. By 2000 they would be eighty years old. My father, who smoked died in 2003 at age 85. Males especially, of my father's age had a very high rate of smokers.

Next off, as smoking is becoming more demonised people may be less likely to admit to smoking if they do smoke. I've talked to a number of "chippers" (occasional smokers) who claim they don't smoke because they can go all week without smoking. Higher prices and smoking restrictions might increase the number of "chippers" who would deny they smoke or refuse to participate in the survey.

This might be like a survey of illegal drug use or binge drinking. Accurate answers require trust in the survey and it's confidentiality and smokers already have a "tension" with the anti-smoking forces. Will "big brother" get your survey answers?
Restriction indeed cause some reduction in smoking but they cause a "tension" with the survey takers which could skew results.


Costs reduce smoking some but there are ways around this. I see non-big tobacco brands for under $30 per carton. Out of state might be cheaper.


http://www.taxadmin.org/FTA/rate/cigarett.html

I have heard that reservation cigs are cheaper and there are internet sales and "roll your own" are well under $10 per carton. Someone taking these routes might be less inclined to cooperate with the survey. I don't smoke but I have been told the "small tobacco" brands are pretty good. The actual cost of the tobacco is a very small portion of the final cost for a carton so quality comes cheap, at least here in the US. The point being that a smoker that gets "creative" may be less likely to cooperate with a survey.

Finally, smokers might react with "alternatives" which they might not share with the survey. Here is a story link "Decline is cigarette sales offset by use of alternative products. http://www.smokingmad.com/decline-in-cigarette-sales-offset-by-use-of-alternative-products.html

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

I recieved my MN refundable $50/100 political donation refund in one month.

Redrant: September 09, 2008 Update. I just checked my checking account online and found a $50 deposit from the Minnesota Department of Revenue. I am waiting for a far larger State Property Tax refund so I "had a cow" when I $50. With a bit of checking I discovered that I had indeed opted for the direct deposit of the $50 campaign donation refund. This is the $50 I received. Here is the timeline for this. The $50 check is dated August 02, so figure it was mailed August 03. The forms needed to receive the refund is postmarked August 06 so figure I

received a day or two later. I recall filling out the forms and sending in the donations quickly so figure I mailed it August 08 to 10. A direct deposit was made on September 05. Thus my $50 was tied up for a bit over a month. Greg Lang

Go to http://spendastamp.com for details on the program.



The original post is pasted below.



Monday, August 11, 2008
Update on my $50 refundable campaign donation.
After a week I didn't hear back from Dave Shegstad but it could have been an email glitch. I sent a $50 check instead to the campaign for Adam Steele who is a very strong opponent of the bar smoking ban. I mailed the $50 check on Monday and received a reply with the forms needed to get a response in the Friday mail. This is a prompt response. It included personal response. I am using a new computer without OCR software but the letter reaffirmed Adam Steele's very strong support for changing the bar smoking ban.Here are web pages I found with information on Adam Steele and his candidacy. http://northernherald.finalhost.net/campsite.pdfhttp://northernherald.finalhost.net/http://northernherald.com/Here is the Tavern League's page on the Campaign Donation refund. http://www.tavernleaguemn.org/PCR.htmHere is the official State of Minnesota page.http://www.taxes.state.mn.us/individ/other_supporting_content/political_contrib_refund.shtmlTo reiterate the basics. You must be a resident of Minnesota but you do not have to donate to a candidate (or political group) in your district. I once donated to a Democratic challenger in Burnsville, and got my refund. On off years in the past I have made this donation to the state Republican party but I have had second thoughts about this. Not matter how explicitly you tell them that this will be the only contribution that year they will still call seeking more. I've had people tell it's the same with the Democratic donations. Besides, it seems more effective to give to an individual candidate, especially one who shares your views. Adam Steele is running for district 4A in Bemidji and I live in Minneapolis. This is a perfectly legal and acceptable way to give the refundable donation.Some ground rules and caveats. The candidate has to agree to campaign spending limits to be eligible and must be running for a Minnesota constitutional office or be a Minnesota political party. What this means is that you won't be eligible for a refund if you donate to the "Paris Hilton for President" campaign http://www.funnyordie.com/videos/64ad536a6d . The National congressional campaigns are not eligible either.Basically local is better. Adam Steele is eligible. If you send a check to any candidate for this write "refundable MN political contribution" on the check. If the candidate did not agree they are required to send the check back. Again, Adam Steele sent me the refund material back promptly so he is definitely eligible.Send a note with your concerns to the candidate. This is why it is better to donate to an individual candidate. Adam Steele sent me a personalised reply. $50/$100 means a lot to these candidates and raising basic money will make them eligible for further campaign financing.One important caveat is that if you owe municipalities in Minnesota or the State of Minnesota debts, fines and penalties the $50/100 refund can be seized for this. This could conceivably include unpaid first half property taxes and other taxes in arrears. The second half property taxes are not due until (I think) October 15 so these are non in arrears. Basically, if you got your state and federal tax refunds and economic stimulus checks intact and haven't received arrears notices since then you should be OK. They cross check for arrears child support but again if you got your refunds you should be OK.The donations must be monetary, not goods or services. That a technical point but it makes sense.That said, it is a very good program and I highly recommend donations to Adam Steele. He has a long history of aggressively fighting the bar smoking bans so he could be a valuable asset if elected.Basically your "cost" for this donation is two stamps. One is to mail the check and the other is to mail in the application for the refund. The Sate of Minnesota will refund your $50 to $100 within six weeks if you meek the criteria. It is not difficult.The refundable limit is $50 for and individual and $100 for a married couple. This can only be done once per calendar year. It is designed to increase citizen influence in government. $50/100 won't "buy" much influence but it helps support the candidates who support your beliefs.The bar/tavern culture is under assault from the same "global warming" politicians and bureaucrats who believe that if they can drive energy prices up high enough we will all embrace their "Potekem Village" alternative energy fantasies. (MY father ran an electric power plant so I know energy realities, see my http://fourfiftygas.com/) A good way to fight back is with the $50/100 refundable MN campaign contribution.Note to other candidate favoring a MN bar smoking ban revision. Email me through the http://freedomtoact.com/ email link or snail mail me at the address on the far right of http://freedomtoact.com/ and I will publish you comments upon verification.Again, this is a very good program. If people want to help save our American bar/tavern culture they have to do more than gripe. We can all afford two stamps.
Posted by Gregory L Lang at 12:28 AM

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Thursday update from Shiela.

Redrant: I'm sort of pre-occupied with the RNC convention but I soon be digging up a lot of good stuff. Greg Lang

Hello Everyone -

Just a sampling of what's to come if we do not stop the madness. I don't know about you but I personally do not appreciate the government's interference in my private life. I can raise my own children and take care of my own health....I'm not STUPID you know !! I resent the fact that government thinks they need to make choices for me !! Sorry.....but it is my life and not theirs! Stay OUT of my life!

Remember elections this November and lets change the tide! Visit http://www.banthebanminnesota.com/ and view the government scorecard and blog. Know who is running and who the incumbents are...be an informed voter and pass information on....WE CAN DO THIS!! Don't forget to visit the http://www.freedomtoact.com/ website....an interesting article on Alabama state workers, "Obese workers Told to Get Fit". Another good site to get all kinds of information on incumbants is http://www.votesmart.org/mystate_summary.php.

Have a Great Day!
Sheila


France bans tot TV By CHRISTINE OLLIVIER The Associated PressThu. Aug 21 - 4:47 AMPARIS — France’s broadcast authority has banned French channels from airing TV shows aimed at children under three years of age to shield them from developmental risks it says television viewing poses at that age.The High Audiovisual Council, in a ruling published Wednesday, said it wanted to "protect children under three from the effects of television."France’s minister for culture and communication, Christine Albanel, issued a "cry of alarm" to parents in June about channels dedicated 24 hours a day to baby-targeted programming. In a newspaper interview, she called them "a danger" and urged parents not to use them to help their children get to sleep.She was referring to two foreign channels that can be seen in France on cable television, BabyFirstTV and Baby TV.The council’s ruling aims to prevent the development of such programming on French channels. It also orders French cable operators that air foreign channels with programs for babies to broadcast warning messages to parents. The messages will read: "Watching television can slow the development of children under three, even when it involves channels aimed specifically at them."The ruling cites health experts as saying that interaction with other people is crucial to early child development."Television viewing hurts the development of children under 3 years old and poses a certain number of risks, encouraging passivity, slow language acquisition, over-excitedness, troubles with sleep and concentration as well as dependence on screens," the ruling said.When BabyFirstTV first aired in the United States in 2006, it escalated an already heated national debate. The American Academy of Pediatrics has said babies should be kept away from television altogether.http://www.thechron%20icleherald.%20ca/World/%201074393.html

France mulls raising tax on fatty, salty, sugary foods
Updated Wed. Aug. 6 2008 2:19 PM ET
The Associated Press
PARIS -- Cheese, pastries, foie gras -- France's culinary delights are full of dietary sins. Now child obesity is rising and the myth is fading that French people can eat anything and stay thin. So the government is fighting back.
The latest anti-fat idea being presented to French officialdom: an increase in sales taxes on extra-fatty, salty or sugary products.
Previous government efforts included posters suggesting that subway riders take the stairs instead of escalators, and advisories prominently displayed on ads for junk food telling people to eat at least five fruits and vegetables a day.
An expert report suggesting increasing taxes on unhealthy food items from the current 5.5 per cent to up to 19.6 per cent, was submitted to the health and budget ministries in late July, an official from the Budget Ministry confirmed Wednesday. The official could not be cited by name because of ministry rules.
The findings of the report -- which remains confidential because it is still under discussion -- were leaked to Les Echos newspaper Tuesday.
Details of the tax remain to be hammered out.
It was not yet clear, for example, whether it would apply to famously fatty cheese that French consumers buy at outdoor markets and to eclairs from the bakery, or just processed junk foods that have nutritional content listed on their packaging.
The higher sales taxes, if implemented, would go in part toward patching a huge deficit in the French state health-care system.
Last year, France's senators had called for so-called nutritional taxes, but then stepped back from the plan, instead commissioning the expert study to look into its feasibility.
The findings will be presented to legislators in September, said the Budget Ministry official. Legislators could then debate the measures suggested, either in part or as a whole package.
However, the idea of increasing the sales tax already faces stiff opposition from Budget Minister Eric Woerth.
"It is out of the question to raise sales taxes on food products, even more so given the difficult context of the French population's purchasing power," he said Wednesday.
Decreased purchasing power -- caused by inflation and stagnant salaries -- is a growing concern in France, as gas and food prices have shot up over the past year. President Nicolas Sarkozy's conservative government has been working on reforms to make good on his campaign promise to improve spending power.
The expert report was written by France's inspection agencies on social affairs and on finances.
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20080806/france_tax_080806/20080806?hub=Health

Time for tough action on alcoholTOO many words and not enough action is being used to tackle alcohol abuse in Scotland, medics in Edinburgh have said.The British Medical Association has urged the Scottish Government to implement legislation and practical action rather than hard-hitting messages.Dr Peter Terry, the organisation' s chairman, said doctors were in the best position to judge how alcohol affects people's lives.He said: "Doctors witness first-hand how alcohol misuse destroys lives. The facts are simple - voluntary measures implemented by the drinks industry are not effective and do not reduce the damage of alcohol misuse in Scotland."
http://edinburghnews.scotsman.com/health/Time-for-tough-action-on.4413253.jp

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Sheila Kromer: Theater Night Update

Hello Everyone -

It has been a while since my last update. I have read and continue to keep myself informed of the "anti-smoking" policies cropping up all over the nation and beyond. The strategy that the anit-smoking groups use is at least consistent, “Divide and Conquer”. Think about it. They are successful in getting laws passed at a local level (most often with behind the scenes tactics) and this then puts the community at an economic disadvantage with surrounding communities that do not have those laws. Well, guess what follows… a rift between hospitality venues is born, which then divides the industry and everybody logically looks out for themselves. Does “leveling the playing field” sound familiar? If the “anti’s” can encourage “in-fighting” then they gain the upper hand and it is easier for them to conquer small factions then it is an entire army. A fairly good strategy, I must admit. I suggest that all of us in the hospitality industry should also have a strategy, “Do not let them divide us but instead we should all stand together and fight for all of our rights to make our own decisions…be a bar or restaurant. We do not need a law to tell us to go smoke-free...we are smart enough to decide for ourselves to go the smoke free route or not. The only way to have a level playing field is when we in the hospitality industry are free to make our own choices concerning a "legal" product. If we don't band together and look out for each other, many more "choices" will be taken from us in the future. In the future...we should become familar with the word "Preemption" so that we can put a "chink" in the armor of the "do gooders" so that they cannot divide us on a local level !


Did you know that Clearway Minnesota has been "lurking" on the www.banthebanminnesota.com website? I wonder what they were doing there? Well, I would just like to give Clearway a big "WELCOME" to the website and to please feel free to visit anytime and spend as much time as you want. Apparently, the site must be noteworthy since they spent nearly an hour on it.

For any of you that are not familar with Clearway, below is a letter that Sue Jeffers (KTLK 100.3 radio show host) sent to the Attorney General regarding Clearway (aka MPATT).


Letter to Attorney General

To: Attorney General Lori Swanson,

In 1994 MN sued the tobacco companies in the legendary lawsuit netting a judgment of $6.1 billion. In 1998 at judge approved the state plan to create MPAAT and allocating them 3% of the judgment. MPAAT was given a clear mission: to help smokers quit. The plan called for $102 million into a smoking cessation account. Another $100 million was to be used for research.

The tobacco settlement was the first time in MN history that a MN Attorney General and the legislature allowed the collection of litigated funds. Using state and federal offices these funds were specifically to be used by un-elected, non-profit and politically active citizens without legislative oversight. This is a clear violation of our constitution to divert money that rightfully belongs to the people of MN with no public accountability or legislative authority.

Instead, MPAAT/ClearWay has pursued prohibition as its centerpiece. These organizations have provided millions of dollars for campaigns to pass no smoking ordinances including the 2007 state wide smoking ban that has divided communities and damaged businesses, jobs and revenues.

History:
MPAAT was an independent, non-profit organization that improves the health of Minnesotans by reducing the harm caused by tobacco. It serves MN through grant-making programs, QUITPLAN stop smoking services and statewide outreach activities.

Without judicial or legislative approval MPAAT changed its name, missions and goals, clearly outside the scope of its original intent. Becoming ClearWay Minnesota its goal and mission is reflected in the following statement:
ClearWay MinnesotaSM is an independent, nonprofit organization that improves the health of all Minnesotans by reducing the harm caused by tobacco. Our mission is to enhance life in Minnesota by reducing tobacco use and exposure to secondhand smoke through research, action and collaboration.

We use our portion of the settlement to help Minnesotans quit smoking and tobacco use, and to fund research, intervention and community development projects around the state. We work to raise people's awareness of the dangers of tobacco use, and to make Minnesota a safer, healthier place.

I have several complaints against this organization:
MPAAT/ClearWay Minnesota has illegally changed the original scope and mission of its organization without legislative or judicial approval.
Millions of dollars, money that rightfully belongs to the people of MN, continues to be spent on projects, lobbying and advertising outside the scope of the original intentions.
MPAAT president claimed in 2005 that "MPAAT has made tremendous progress with our stop smoking programs." Yet in spite of the millions of dollars that have been spent MPAAT/ClearWay Minnesota' web site claims in 2007 to have assisted 7803 to quit smoking. The program is a failure.
MPAAT/ClearWay has not been held publicly accountable to the people of MN on the expenditure of said public funds recouped in the lawsuit.
ClearWay Minnesota reportedly spent $122,902 on illegal lobbying in the 06 legislative session. This practice is a clear violation public funding and its mission. It is illegal, unethical and unconstitutional for a legislature to fund, with public money, using private citizens to lobby against other citizens for legislative approval.
June 27, 2002 Ramsey County judge ordered MPAAT administrator to stop grants for smoke free indoor air efforts until it has spent a comparable amount on individual cessation efforts.
MPAAT ordered a survey to determine the wishes of the citizens of MN and selectively chose to use a small portion of the survey.
MPAAT/ClearWay Minnesota is not held to the same standards as other non-profit organizations. Required only to send the legislature and the court a progress report every two years for a biannual review.
While ClearWay Minnesota has removed its inaccurate claim that secondhand smoke exposure reduces coronary blood flow in healthy young adults no public correction has been published. Ditto for the 4.000 chemicals, the health care costs, the losses, exposure and risk and OSHA standards.
Current statistics show smoking bans do not help people quit smoking and in fact in some studies show an increase in smoking.
I am requesting a lawsuit by the state of MN, in the name of the people of MN, for the return of all monies illegally spent by MPAAT/ClearWay Minnesota outside the scope of the originally intended legislative and judicial directive from the tobacco settlement.

This should include an intensive and complete investigation of ClearWay Minnesota spending practices, full public disclosure of every dime of taxpayer dollars or settlement monies ever spent by ClearWay and MPAAT and the return of all moneys illegally spent by this organization.

Finally, I am requesting a full-page apology printed in every newspaper in the state of MN announcing this organization willfully and knowingly intended to deceive the people of Minnesota about the effects of secondhand smoke. This apology should include OSHA’s statement stating ventilated bars and restaurants are safe.

Sincerely,
Sue Jeffers

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Obese state workers in Alabama told to get fit or pay insurance fees

Hey Greg - Can We post.

Thanks,
Sheila


Obese state workers in Alabama told to get fit or pay insurance fees
By Phillip Rawls ASSOCIATED PRESS
August 22, 2008
MONTGOMERY, Ala. – Alabama, pushed to second in national obesity rankings by deep-fried Southern favorites, is cracking down on state workers who are too fat.
The state has given its 37,527 employees a year to start getting fit – or they'll pay $25 a month for insurance that otherwise is free.
Alabama will be the first state to charge overweight state workers who don't work on slimming down. A few states reward employees who adopt healthy behaviors.
Alabama charges workers who smoke – and has seen some success in getting them to quit – but has turned its attention to a problem that plagues many in the Deep South: obesity.
The State Employees' Insurance Board approved a plan this week to charge state workers starting in 2010 if they don't go to free health screenings.
If the screenings turn up serious problems with blood pressure, cholesterol, glucose or obesity, employees will have a year to see a doctor at no cost, enroll in a wellness program, or take steps themselves to improve their health. If they show progress in a follow-up screening, they won't be charged. But if they don't, they must pay, starting in 2011.
“We are trying to get individuals to become more aware of their health,” said state worker Robert Wagstaff, who serves on the insurance board.
Not all state employees see it that way. “It's terrible,” said health department employee Chequla Motley. “Some people come into this world big.”
Computer technician Tim Colley already pays $24 a month for being a smoker and doesn't like the idea of another charge. “It's too Big Brotherish,” he said.
The board will apply the obesity charge to anyone with a body mass index of 35 or higher who isn't making progress. A person 5 feet 6 inches tall and weighing 220 pounds, for example, would have a BMI of 35.5. A BMI of 30 is considered the threshold for obesity.
The board hasn't determined how much progress a person would have to show and isn't certain how many people might be affected because everyone could avoid the charge by working to lose weight.
But that's unlikely: Government statistics show Alabamians have a big weight problem. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 30.3 percent of them are now obese, ranking the state behind only Mississippi.
http://www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20080822/news_1n22obesity.html

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Drinking-Age Revolt Gains Converts In State (Con­necticut)

If you want to read the article first http://www.courant.com/news/politics/hc-drinking0820.artaug20,0,7336823.story?page=1

Redrant: This initiative caught me by surprise. Smoking ban news is slow so I tried to read up on this. First off, my opinion/position on this which I have just formulated.

First off, I'd propose an 18 to 21 age alcohol for beer and wine under 6% alcohol with not distilled alcohol fortification. This is un update on the old 3.2 beer. The vast majority of beer is under 6% alcohol. Some specialty beers and wines have natural alcohol content up to 20% and we don't want an "arms race" here.

I would stay away from any distilled alcohol for 18 to 21 including things wine "coolers" that used distilled alcohol. In the black market of 18 to 20 drinking you aren't going to smuggle a case of beer into a dorm room. I've always considered distilled "hard" liquor to have a much much more of an effect than naturally fermented alcohol. I know of people who can drink regular beer or wine without problem but if they have something like a Jack Daniels cooler they tend to black out. The 18 to 20 drinkers aren't at that stage but the "bootleg" booze is typically the "hard stuff". It's a radical proposal but worth debating.

An interesting irony is that the 21 year old uniform drinking age started in the Orwellian year of 1984. The tool devised then was the withholding of federal funds if states did not pass laws like raising the drinking age to 21.

I've read quite a few articles on the Amethyst Initiative in the last few days. There were a lot of online polls with vague questions but these polls came up close to 50/50, much like the bar smoking polls.

Another factor is potential liability for colleges. You would need airport security level measures at dorms and other college facilities to try to stop "bootlegging". Besides the cost this would be very oppressive.

Added to that there is an "entertainment gap" for 18 to 20 year olds. This lead to things like Raves and a breeding ground for compulsive gambling and (ironically) smoking. Indian/Native American casinos tend to have a age of 18 and you can smoke there. I see Mystik Lake shuttle buses on Lake Street all the time. Greg Lang

http://www.courant.com/news/politics/hc-drinking0820.artaug20,0,7336823.story?page=1

courant.com/news/politics/hc-drinking0820.artaug20,0,7336823.story
Courant.com
Drinking-Age Revolt Gains Converts In State
August 20, 2008

James F. Jones Jr., who is in his fifth year as president of Trinity College, knows he is incurring the wrath of Mothers Against Drunk Driving, and probably more than a few parents, by suggesting that the drinking age be lowered. But, frankly, he doesn't really care.He's that fed up with the consequences of what he calls "the clandestine culture" of underage drinking among college students. It's a culture, Jones and other college administrators say, that has led to some very danger­ous, and often tragic, behavior."Who in the world is going to stand up against Mothers Against Drunk Driving? It would be like standing up against motherhood and apple pie," Jones said. "But [the current drinking age] is counterproductive because it simply fosters this counterculture of binge drinking, which is epidemic at colleges."Jones is one of six college presidents from Con­necticut who have joined the Amethyst Initiative, roughly 100 university administrators calling on lawmakers to consider lowering the drinking age from 21 to 18.The movement, started by John McCardell, former president of Middlebury College in Vermont, has been gathering supporters across the United States for about a year. In addition to Trinity, Connecticut schools that have joined are the University of Hartford, St. Joseph College, Fairfield University, the Uni­versity of New Haven and Mitchell College in New London.Binge drinking has been a tragic problem at college campuses across the United States, including Connecticut. One of the best known incidents oc­curred at Quinnipiac University in Hamden in 2001, when junior Matt Oliveri died of alcohol poisoning after a night of binge drinking.Jones, like some of the other Connecticut administrators who have signed on to the movement, has emotional, practical and philosophical reasons for wanting the issue debated again, 23 years after the drinking age was raised to 21 in Connecticut.First, the practical."The fact that kids can't drink until they're 21 legally simply forces them to do it clandestinely, and when they do, you get irresponsible be­havior in the residence halls," Jones said. "You get younger students getting older students to go to the liquor store for them, and you get the binge drinking in the dorm rooms."Jones also has trouble with the disconnect in the message the government is sending 18­year-olds, who can vote, serve on a jury, sign a contract and serve in the military -- but not drink."If we're going to send some­one to fight in Iraq, I don't understand why that is an adult prerogative but buying a beer legally is not," Jones said, adding that students don't be­lieve the drinking age limit should apply to them, in part, because of this disconnect.J. Lee Peters, vice president for student affairs at the Uni­versity of Hartford, agreed and said the scope of underage binge drinking problem is enormous."I have hundreds of students, and I know every other college administrator has the same thing, who are sitting in their rooms throwing down multiple drinks so they can pre-load [their bodies with alcohol] before going out," Peters said. "It's a recipe for disaster."Peters said he saw firsthand what happens when the illegal­ity issue is removed from drinking when he helped lead a semester at sea in 2004 with 440 college students from around the country.Once the ship left shore and entered international waters, Peters said, there was no drink­ing age, which meant that the 18- to 22-year-old students on board could socialize -- and drink -- openly with the facul­ty on the trip. Because of that openness, Peters said, he and staff members could monitor what was happening, and there were fewer incidents of drunk­en behavior."Before I went on that trip, I wasn't a big fan of this [idea]," Peters said. "I thought it was kind of a cop-out, to try to change the law rather than work within the law. But I learned you have much more influence on a student by dealing with their behavior and not [focusing on] whether they broke the law."The MADD ViewOfficials with both the national and state offices of MADD would say that lowering the drinking age is a cop-out, however, and will lead to more fatal car accidents. They also maintain that studies have clearly shown raising the drinking age has reduced drunken-driving deaths nationally -- a claim backed up by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and others.In fact, according to a federal study of fatal drunken-driving accidents from 1982 to 1998, Connecticut saw a decline of about 85 percent in accidents involving drivers age 16-20."We're opening up the flood­gates here," said Janice Heggie Margolis, executive director of the Connecticut chapter of MADD.Margolis said that while the higher age limit has helped decrease the number of fatal accidents, she and other MADD officials are concerned that people have become com­placent recently. She cited a national study showing Connecticut experienced an 11 percent increase in fatal drunken­driving accidents in 2006."We know that we must continue to decrease access and availability of alcohol to young adults, and if we drop the 21-year-old drinking age, that's going to make it that much easier for young people to get alcohol," Margolis said.College administrators, though, say that students are continually finding new ways to obtain alcohol illegally and that the law simply isn't stopping them."There's an entire fake-ID industry," Jones said.State Rep. Michael Lawlor agreed.Lawlor, an East Haven Democrat who serves as both the chairman of the legislature's powerful judiciary committee and as an associate professor of criminal justice at the University of New Haven, said students are "very resourceful" when it comes to getting around the drinking age law."You can get a fake driver's license for $60. They look very real and all the kids have them," Lawlor said.He said he can't envision the state lowering its drinking age without a corresponding move by the federal government, though. That's because of the 1984 National Minimum Drinking Age Act, which imposes a 10 percent penalty on a state's federal highway grant if it lowers the drinking age below 21.But that doesn't mean it shouldn't be discussed, he said. "It's worth talking about," Lawlor said. "If in fact you can pass a law to stop the behavior, then it's a good idea to pass the law. But if you pass the law and it makes [the situation] worse, which is arguably what is hap­pening, then you need to re­think it." That's where Pamela Trotman Reid, president of St. Joseph College, comes down.Reid said a public discussion about the issue, and a closer, more informed look at the data, are imperative because the problem of underage drinking is so acute.She said she's not convinced that raising the drinking age is the only factor contributing to a decrease in drunken-driving fatalities, and wonders if in­creased education, stiffer legal consequences and the intro­duction of the concept of desig­nated drivers have played equal parts.And, like Jones, Reid wants the issue reopened because she has seen firsthand the tragic consequences when students shut themselves up in their rooms to drink, where no one can monitor them."When I was at the Univer­sity of Michigan, a female stu­dent fell out of her dorm win­dow after a night of binge drinking and died," Reid said. "No one wants to be in that position, to have to face parents and tell them their child has died."Senior Information Specialist Cristina Bachetti contributed to this report.Contact Elizabeth Hamilton at ehamilton@courant.com.