Sunday, October 5, 2008

Philip Morris and Walgreens File Suit Over San Francisco's Ban on Tobacco Sales at Pharmacies

Philip Morris and Walgreens File Suit Over San Francisco's Ban on Tobacco Sales at Pharmacies

In two separate lawsuits, Philip Morris and Walgreens are challenging the constitutionality of San Francisco's recently enacted ban on tobacco sales in pharmacies. Philip Morris has filed suit in federal court, arguing that it has a First Amendment right to sell its products. Walgreens filed suit in San Francisco Superior Court, arguing that the regulation is unfair because its treats various types of retailers differently.

According to an article in the San Francisco Chronicle: "Philip Morris USA, the nation's largest tobacco company, filed suit in federal court Wednesday, arguing the city of San Francisco has unconstitutionally banned pharmacies from selling tobacco products. ... Philip Morris is arguing that it has a First Amendment right of free expression to sell its products. 'Although called a ban on sales, the purpose and effect of the ordinance is to suppress communications directed to adult smokers, in violation of our constitutional rights,' said Joe Murillo, a lawyer representing Philip Morris USA. 'Likewise, the ban unfairly deprives adult consumers of the opportunity to buy tobacco products from legitimate, licensed retail businesses.'"

"Mitch Katz, director of the city's Department of Public Health, remarked that he must have missed the day in social studies class the teacher discussed the constitutionality of cigarette sales. 'Do you remember any part of the Bill of Rights being about pharmacies selling tobacco?' he asked." ...

"Walgreens, meanwhile, filed a brief Wednesday stating the company would lose millions of dollars, equal to 9 percent of a store's non-pharmacy sales, if the ban takes effect. The company said the city is discriminating by not applying the ban to grocery stores or big-box stores that have pharmacies within them and also sell cigarettes. Katz has said it's a contradictory message for Walgreens to use the motto "the pharmacy America trusts" while selling cancer-causing tobacco products. In its brief, Walgreens said grocery stores are also perceived as health-promoting venues and pointed out that Safeway's slogan is "ingredients for life" but that the chain also sells cigarettes."

According to another article in the San Francisco Chronicle: "Attorneys for Walgreens are seeking an emergency injunction to stop San Francisco from banning the sale of tobacco products in pharmacies. In July, San Francisco became the first city in the nation to ban the sale of tobacco products in pharmacies such as Walgreens and Rite Aid, saying sick people getting their prescriptions filled shouldn't be faced with cancer-causing products sitting nearby. But the ban, which is scheduled to take effect Oct. 1, doesn't extend to grocery stores or big-box stores that also have pharmacies. That's why the company wants the plan stopped, said Walgreens spokeswoman Tiffani Bruce. 'Our position is based solely on being fair across different types of retailers,' she said, noting that smokers will just buy their cigarettes at another store down the block."

http://tobaccoanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, October 4, 2008

VCR Alert: At Issues KSTP: 10AM Sunday. Theater Night Update 10-3-08

Hello Everyone -
 
Below are 2 articles posted in the Post Bulletin. One article is by Clearway and the other is by Shawn (banthebanminnesota) about the smoking ban.
Both are worth reading....things seem to be heating up lately. On channel KSTP 5 this Sunday at 10:00 on "At Issues", Sue Jeffers will be debating Senator Sheran about the ban.  Don't forget to check out the www.freedomtoact.com website and thewww.banthebanminnesota.com website!
 
 
On with the Show!
Sheila
 
 
 
If you clink on this link below, you will see the actual newspaper articles side by side.

Both sides: Evidence proves Freedom to Breathe is working

10/1/2008 8:50:55 AM
By David J. Willoughby

The first anniversary of Minnesota's Freedom to Breathe Act is a testament to how thoughtful public policy can make Minnesota a better place to live and work. By virtually every measure, the statewide law protecting employees and customers from secondhand smoke is an overwhelming success.

Freedom to Breathe, along with the local smoke-free policies in Olmsted County and other Minnesota communities that preceded the statewide law, is delivering on every promise. For example, a study conducted by the University of Minnesota Cancer Center found that the exposure of hospitality workers to tobacco-specific cancer-causing chemicals decreased by 80 percent or more after the law's implementation.

Smoke-free policies also encourage smokers to quit. The Minnesota Adult Tobacco Survey released last month showed that the state's smoking rate declined to a new low of 17 percent, significantly better than the national rate. Conducted before the Freedom to Breathe law went into effect, the data do reflect the positive impact of Minnesota's 15 local smoke-free ordinances in helping people quit. In fact, 164,000 Minnesotans have quit smoking since 1999. These data provide great encouragement that we will continue to see even more progress in reducing the smoking rate as the impact of the Freedom to Breathe law is registered in future surveys.

These achievements give all Minnesotans cause to celebrate. Tobacco use remains the leading cause of preventable death and disease and is responsible for nearly $2 billion in excess medical costs in Minnesota. Reducing tobacco use and protecting people from secondhand smoke can help improve health, save lives and control health care costs for everyone.

Certainly, the new law has brought changes to some Minnesota bars and restaurants. Kenn Rockler, executive director of the Tavern League of Minnesota and vocal smoke-free opponent, recently was quoted as saying that the impact on bars and restaurants has been uneven and that "not everyone was damaged." He's right -- in reality, those establishments that approached the law with an open mind have found more success than those who have resisted the changes brought about by the law.

The observations of Rockler and others confirm scientific research in Minnesota and elsewhere that reflect a neutral-to-positive economic impact from smoke-free policies. More competition in the industry, a difficult economy and changing legal and social attitudes toward drinking have a much greater impact on the hospitality industry than smoke-free policies do.

Ultimately, the long-term success of Freedom to Breathe -- and the economic opportunities for bars and restaurants -- rests on public support. There again, the law is a winner. In a survey released last week, 77 percent of Minnesotans support the law, with an even higher percentage -- 86 percent -- saying bars and restaurants now are healthier places. With smoke-free policies helping to drive the smoking rate to a historic low, the opportunity for bars and restaurants is to attract new customers by celebrating their fresh indoor air

And on this first anniversary of Freedom to Breathe, it is an occasion for all Minnesotans to celebrate that good public policy delivers good public outcomes.

David Willoughby is chief executive officer of ClearWay Minnesota, a non-profit agency created a decade ago with state tobacco settlement money to reduce tobacco use and exposure to secondhand smoke through research, action and collaboration.

 

 

  http://www.postbulletin.com/newsmanager/templates/localnews_story.asp?z=12&a=364119

Both sides: Compromise, and allow business to cater to smokers

10/1/2008 8:50:55 AM
By Shawn Gertken

Now that it's been a year since the start of the statewide smoking ban, you will undoubtedly be seeing many media campaigns that state that the overwhelming majority of Minnesota residents support the ban, Minnesotans are healthier now, and that it's business as usual.

You won't be seeing or hearing much about the other side of the story, at least not through your normal media outlets.

While many chain restaurants have not realized much of an impact of the smoking ban, there are hundreds of small businesses that catered to smokers and have seen sales drops of 20 percent to 40 percent or more. Minnesota charities have also lost millions of dollars in charitable gambling that are directly attributed to the smoking ban. This is clearly evidenced by the Charitable Gambling Impact Study released in March by the Minnesota Gambling Control Board. This study shows a loss of $40 million in three months.

Unfortunately, the anti-smoking forces have millions of dollars received from the tobacco settlement, among other sources, that they use to advertise the "success" of the ban. Since the small bar owners are now losing money or even going out of business, they can't afford to counter these claims.

The anti-smoking forces also possess a survey that states that more than 75 percent of Minnesotans support the ban. However, the survey respondents and survey results can easily be manipulated by targeting a specific demographic, toning the questions in a specific manner, or by other methods.

A survey was also conducted by a media outlet about a year ago that resulted in more than half of the respondents stating that they prefer that bar owners should make the choice of allowing smoking.

The anti-smoking organizations and legislators have made it very clear that they do not support compromise. However, a common-sense approach, such as allowing bars the option to allow smoking by upgrading their ventilation systems, or by granting hardship waivers to the small businesses that have been financially devastated by the smoking ban, would go a long way in helping these businesses.

There are more than 85 candidates running for the Minnesota House of Representatives this fall that support compromise. In a country founded on liberty and compromise, allowing small business that cater to smokers is the right thing to do.

Shawn Gertken of Rochester is a member of Ban the Ban Minnesota, Inc. (www.banthebanminnesota.com) a non-profit organization dedicated to having Minnesota's smoking ban rescinded.




-----Original Message-----
From: Sheila Kromer
To: sheiladk@comcast.net
Sent: Sat, 4 Oct 2008 2:28 am
Subject: Can We Post - Theater Night Update 10-3-08

 
Hello Everyone -
 
Below are 2 articles posted in the Post Bulletin. One article is by Clearway and the other is by Shawn (banthebanminnesota) about the smoking ban.
Both are worth reading....things seem to be heating up lately. On channel KSTP 5 this Sunday at 10:00 on "At Issues", Sue Jeffers will be debating Senator Sheran about the ban.  Don't forget to check out the www.freedomtoact.com website and the www.banthebanminnesota.com website!
 
 
On with the Show!
Sheila
 
 
 
If you clink on this link below, you will see the actual newspaper articles side by side.

Both sides: Evidence proves Freedom to Breathe is working

10/1/2008 8:50:55 AM
By David J. Willoughby

The first anniversary of Minnesota's Freedom to Breathe Act is a testament to how thoughtful public policy can make Minnesota a better place to live and work. By virtually every measure, the statewide law protecting employees and customers from secondhand smoke is an overwhelming success.

Freedom to Breathe, along with the local smoke-free policies in Olmsted County and other Minnesota communities that preceded the statewide law, is delivering on every promise. For example, a study conducted by the University of Minnesota Cancer Center found that the exposure of hospitality workers to tobacco-specific cancer-causing chemicals decreased by 80 percent or more after the law's implementation.

Smoke-free policies also encourage smokers to quit. The Minnesota Adult Tobacco Survey released last month showed that the state's smoking rate declined to a new low of 17 percent, significantly better than the national rate. Conducted before the Freedom to Breathe law went into effect, the data do reflect the positive impact of Minnesota's 15 local smoke-free ordinances in helping people quit. In fact, 164,000 Minnesotans have quit smoking since 1999. These data provide great encouragement that we will continue to see even more progress in reducing the smoking rate as the impact of the Freedom to Breathe law is registered in future surveys.

These achievements give all Minnesotans cause to celebrate. Tobacco use remains the leading cause of preventable death and disease and is responsible for nearly $2 billion in excess medical costs in Minnesota. Reducing tobacco use and protecting people from secondhand smoke can help improve health, save lives and control health care costs for everyone.

Certainly, the new law has brought changes to some Minnesota bars and restaurants. Kenn Rockler, executive director of the Tavern League of Minnesota and vocal smoke-free opponent, recently was quoted as saying that the impact on bars and restaurants has been uneven and that "not everyone was damaged." He's right -- in reality, those establishments that approached the law with an open mind have found more success than those who have resisted the changes brought about by the law.

The observations of Rockler and others confirm scientific research in Minnesota and elsewhere that reflect a neutral-to-positive economic impact from smoke-free policies. More competition in the industry, a difficult economy and changing legal and social attitudes toward drinking have a much greater impact on the hospitality industry than smoke-free policies do.

Ultimately, the long-term success of Freedom to Breathe -- and the economic opportunities for bars and restaurants -- rests on public support. There again, the law is a winner. In a survey released last week, 77 percent of Minnesotans support the law, with an even higher percentage -- 86 percent -- saying bars and restaurants now are healthier places. With smoke-free policies helping to drive the smoking rate to a historic low, the opportunity for bars and restaurants is to attract new customers by celebrating their fresh indoor air

And on this first anniversary of Freedom to Breathe, it is an occasion for all Minnesotans to celebrate that good public policy delivers good public outcomes.

David Willoughby is chief executive officer of ClearWay Minnesota, a non-profit agency created a decade ago with state tobacco settlement money to reduce tobacco use and exposure to secondhand smoke through research, action and collaboration.

 

 

  http://www.postbulletin.com/newsmanager/templates/localnews_story.asp?z=12&a=364119

Both sides: Compromise, and allow business to cater to smokers

10/1/2008 8:50:55 AM
By Shawn Gertken

Now that it's been a year since the start of the statewide smoking ban, you will undoubtedly be seeing many media campaigns that state that the overwhelming majority of Minnesota residents support the ban, Minnesotans are healthier now, and that it's business as usual.

You won't be seeing or hearing much about the other side of the story, at least not through your normal media outlets.

While many chain restaurants have not realized much of an impact of the smoking ban, there are hundreds of small businesses that catered to smokers and have seen sales drops of 20 percent to 40 percent or more. Minnesota charities have also lost millions of dollars in charitable gambling that are directly attributed to the smoking ban. This is clearly evidenced by the Charitable Gambling Impact Study released in March by the Minnesota Gambling Control Board. This study shows a loss of $40 million in three months.

Unfortunately, the anti-smoking forces have millions of dollars received from the tobacco settlement, among other sources, that they use to advertise the "success" of the ban. Since the small bar owners are now losing money or even going out of business, they can't afford to counter these claims.

The anti-smoking forces also possess a survey that states that more than 75 percent of Minnesotans support the ban. However, the survey respondents and survey results can easily be manipulated by targeting a specific demographic, toning the questions in a specific manner, or by other methods.

A survey was also conducted by a media outlet about a year ago that resulted in more than half of the respondents stating that they prefer that bar owners should make the choice of allowing smoking.

The anti-smoking organizations and legislators have made it very clear that they do not support compromise. However, a common-sense approach, such as allowing bars the option to allow smoking by upgrading their ventilation systems, or by granting hardship waivers to the small businesses that have been financially devastated by the smoking ban, would go a long way in helping these businesses.

There are more than 85 candidates running for the Minnesota House of Representatives this fall that support compromise. In a country founded on liberty and compromise, allowing small business that cater to smokers is the right thing to do.

Shawn Gertken of Rochester is a member of Ban the Ban Minnesota, Inc. (www.banthebanminnesota.com) a non-profit organization dedicated to having Minnesota's smoking ban rescinded.

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Post-Bulletin Opinion: Should state smoking ban continue?

Click on image for larger, readable picture.

There is also an on-line version at Post Bulletin with comments (links below). I couldn't resist making a few comments!

http://www.postbulletin.com/newsmanager/templates/localnews_story.asp?z=12&a=364120 Clearway's article

http://www.postbulletin.com/newsmanager/templates/localnews_story.asp?z=12&a=364119
Banthebanminnesota's article


Tuesday, September 30, 2008

One year since the Orwellian named "Freedom to Breath Act" went into affect here in Minnesota.



My "redrant" that did not seem to take there so I will post it here.
209+ comments! There is definitely interest. I run the website http://freedomtoact.com

It just passed 10,000 "hits". Both of these show a definite interest in the subject. 

First off, an appeal has been filed on the test case. I posted the appeal filing http://presslord.com/cigap.html The deadline for filing rebuttal comments should be a week or two before the elections. I'll will definitely post them on my Presslord.com and link at FreedomToAct.com. 

For the record, I quit smoking in the early 1970's but strongly support smokers rights. I made an effort when the Minneapolis bar ban was first enacted in early 2005. To quit I had to dodge smoke for six months. This was not easy before Minnesota's original so-called "Clean Air Act". which I tend to support. I generally support efforts at "practical avoidance". In this realm, I had reports that after the ban Minneapolis stage theaters, specifically the Minneapolis Jungle Theater allowed smoking on stage without signage or advance notifications. This would have put me in a bind had this occurred the first months after I quit. Secondhand smoking triggered a strong cig craving the first few months after I quit. Something the "antis" and the drug companies, who make commercials of these with "the patch" talking to smokers fail to acknowledge.

First off, the new exemptions would have stringent requirements and apply mostly to legacy fraternal organisations like VFW's and establishments without a kitchen or a food menu much beyond the frozen pizza heated in a countertop electric oven. Also, a good electrostatic precipatator and ventalation system would be need along with prominent signage saying that smoking is allowed. The irony here is that this is strongly supported in small towns and rural areas where there are few entertainment choices but "politically" in the larger metropolitan areas where there are abundant dining/entertainment options the political opposition to this "tavern solution" is greatest. Go figure!

A couple of points on surveys. I a day or so MTC bus and LRT fares are going up a quarter. The mid 1990's bus strike debunked the claim that not having the MTC would gridlock traffic. It turned out that only 2% of Twin Cities residences were fully dependent on public transit and only 20% regularly used it. Gosh darned! I never seem to see surveys about what share of the "cost to society" MTC riders should bear? 

Second is welfare. I favor a constitutional amendment to the Minnesota constitution that would have the strictest residency requirements of any state in the US. Gosh darned! We never see a survey on that among likely voters. The maximum residency limit would be at most one to five years and most Minnesotans could "do the math". Nearly 25% of Hennepin County "welfare" payments are to immigrants and a large portion are to those who had not had a history of gainful employment in Minnesota before applying for welfare benefits. The police blotter shows the same pattern. How come no surveys of Minnesotans who, for the most part have been long term, law abiding, productive residents of Minnesota.

A generation of the "skilled trades" has worked in Minnesota since the original "MN clean air act". I think a lot of them chose the skilled trades because they could smoke. The works is less sedentary than an office so overall, they probably came close to breaking even, compared to "desk jockeys" when it came to health risks. 

Now these people, who make very good money are starting to retire and there are a lot of problems finding replacement people, virtually guaranteed a job for life who can now be fired for smoking in their work truck when driving. Next time your furnace quits at -20 below I suggest you call a company and demand a non-smoking repair-person
.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Fat Police on Patrol: Theater Night Update 09-23-08


Hello Everyone -
 
Would you like to get blown away with some of the newest tactics that are being used on the smokers and the obese. How does the sound of the Smoke Police and the Fat Police sit with you! How do you get away from this madness?
 
Don't lose hope! Let's use our votes!
 
Sheila
 
 
 
 

'Smoking police' hit the streets to shock people into quitting

By Daily Mail Reporter
Last updated at 11:16 AM on 18th September 2008 

Smokers will soon be stopped and asked to take a breath test to try to shock them into quitting

Smokers will be stopped in the street and asked to take a carbon monoxide test in London's most hard-hitting anti-smoking campaign. 

'Smoking police' will target people at betting shops, bus stops and shopping centres to shock them into giving up cigarettes. 

They will be asked to breathe into a monitor to show how much carbon monoxide is in their bodies, and could then be signed up to local stop-smoking services and given access to counsellors. 

Pro-smoking group Forest described the campaign as a humiliating infringement of civil liberties. 

Ealing Primary Care Trust, which is funding the £75,000 scheme, said it could help 2,400 people to give up.

A team of 11 young people have been employed to approach smokers, in a similar way to charity fund-raisers  -  nicknamed 'chuggers'  -  who ask passers-by for donations. 

Project spokeswoman Fran Pearce admitted: 'They will have to be careful when approaching smokers in case they become aggressive, but we are interested to see how it pans out. If someone says no, they will not pressure them to take the test.'

Project manager Phil Robinson of Ealing Stop Smoking-Service said: 'The law to ban smoking in public places was hugely effective, but since then some focus has been lost. 

'We want to put stopping smoking back on the agenda, so 50 per cent of our current activity is about personalising and localising our campaign and taking our message direct to smokers.'

He added: 'We will be focusing on betting shops, transport stops, walk-throughs, shopping centres and leisure areas where most smoking takes place.'

There are 75,000 smokers in Ealing, and it is hoped 7,500 will take the new test, with 2,400 going on to quit completely. 

Forest spokesman Neil Rafferty said: 'It shows the authorities think they have a blank cheque to treat smokers how they want  -  to harass, humiliate and victimise them. 

'This is an outrageous abuse of freedom and privacy. It is the health Nazi equivalent of chuggers.'

 
 
 

September 16, 2008

The logic of public health

Imagine shopping at the mall or supermarket and someone wearing a bright-colored vest approaches to talk to you about your being fat and wants to measure your waist. Would you be happy to discuss your weight with a stranger and welcome the unsolicited diet and exercise advice?

Thought not...

Fat-buster street nurses are being sent out into the community as part of the latest initiative of public health officials at the NHS Ayrshire and Arran. According to the news coverage, people are happy to discuss their weight with a nurse off the street; answer questions about their private lifestyles, smoking and drinking habits; be referred to weight loss meetings; and even have the street nurse contact their doctor.

Convincing the public that “everyone else thinks this is okay, so you should to” is a common marketing approach, employing the bandwagon effect. But is it evidence of sound public health policy?

Since this program is not unlike the national health corps envisioned as part of the office of the National Nurse to promote the U.S. Surgeon General’s preventive health initiatives, you might be interested in how it’s showing to be a valuable use of public healthcare resources in Scotland. As Scotsman reports on the new program:

Fat-buster nurses won't give an inch

A TEAM of NHS nurses is patrolling Scotland's streets to target pot-bellied members of the public and tell them how to lose weight. Armed with measuring tapes to check waists and equipment to test blood pressure, the "Street Nurses" are policing busy shopping centres, supermarkets and community centres... The move is part of a scheme by NHS Ayrshire and Arran to target members of the public in its most deprived areas... If they spot someone who looks overweight they will approach them and strike up a conversation about their health, inviting them to have a "rapid nursing assessment"...

Any man with a paunch, or woman with an "apple-shaped" body whose waist measurement is higher than recommended limits is given diet and lifestyle advice or referred to local slimming classes. For women this would be a waist measurement of more than 32 inches and for men over 37 inches because middle regions larger than these are linked with an increased risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, bowel and liver cancer, and strokes... Overweight women can be referred to local Weight Watchers meetings, and men are sent to the NHS Ayrshire and Arran men-only weight loss club 'Slimmin Withoot Wimmin'...

Shoppers are also asked about other aspects of their lifestyle and given advice on how to quit smoking or cut down on alcohol if they admit drinking more than the recommended weekly limits.

The news story went on to quote a Street Nurse who said that people “were usually happy to discuss their weight if it meant getting some good diet and exercise advice... People honestly aren't that shy. It's a bit of light-heartedness, but getting a serious message across. People are generally OK about us talking about their weight...” The article also repeated three times the importance of waist circumference, as a risk factor for “obesity-related” chronic diseases like heart disease. There was no critical look at the medical evidence of waistline measurements.

But the media didn’t follow-up on an even more critical concern raised by Margaret Watt, Scotland’s Patients Association chairperson. NHS Ayrshire and Arran is the first health board to begin a street nurse program for deprived areas, an initiative supported National Obesity Forum. Watt, however, said this program wouldn’t make sense unless there were enough nurses and doctors where they were needed.

While the national health service is diverting nurses from medical facilities and sending them out in waistcoats to hunt down fat people and give them weight loss advice — advice that’s known to be ineffective — who is caring for the sick patients? There’s no evidence that the severe nursing shortage has suddenly disappeared, yet just months ago the NHS baby care units were reported as being at the breaking point because there weren’t enough nurses, which was putting babies’ lives in danger. Just days ago, hospitals in Ayrshire and Arran reported a severe shortage of junior doctors, especially needed in acute medicine. NHS officials are scrambling to fill the gaps in care and extending the use of nurse practitioners and developing contingency plans to care for patients.

Is sending out nurses to go after fat people really the best use of strapped medical personnel or limited healthcare resources?

Just two weeks ago, on August 1st, the NHS Ayrshire and Arran released its 60-age executive summary draft strategy, “Promoting health and reducing health inequalities strategy 2007-2012,” outlining the most pressing public health needs facing Ayrshire and Arran. The report’s key points were that health in Ayrshire and Arran is improving and premature deaths from cancer, heart disease and stroke are down and improving, although Scotland lags behind the rest of the UK.

“Efforts have become more focused on reducing health inequalities and inequalities in access to services, with an increased focus on evidence based practice leading to more effective methods being employed,” it states. According to this report:

Evidence clearly shows that the major causes of health inequalities are poverty, unemployment, poor housing and homelessness. Other factors include people living in rural locations and the difficulty accessing services. Inequalities can be a result of race, gender and poor health literacy.

The authors outlined the complex issues surrounding poverty that need to be addressed, defining poverty as:

Poverty is a condition in which a person or community is deprived of, or lacks the essentials for a minimum standard of well being and life. Since poverty is understood in many senses, these essentials may be material resources such as food, safe drinking water and shelter or they may be social resources such as access to information, education and health care, social status, political power, or the opportunity to develop meaningful connections with other people in society..

There are many other issues which impact more on some groups than others, for example,suicide through drug use, mortality through violence and road traffic accidents (a leading cause of death in young people and where there is huge inequity) which similarly are not currently the focus of national targets. It is important to establish appropriate local targets which will inform the targeting of efforts to achieve the aims of this strategy for all groups in society.


“Well care, not sick care”

If you’re a poor mother with a sick baby, it appears you may find a nurse at the mall, although she’ll want to pull out a tape measure and talk to you about your figure. The focus of public health officials on both sides of the pond increasingly appears to be caring for well people, rather than sick people.

Revised 10-19-08 posting, intended posting.

Sent: Friday, September 19, 2008 1:01 AM
Subject: Fw: Theater Night Update 9-19-08

Hello Everyone -

Our elected officials are something aren't they! In this update are a couple things that our elected officials have been up to....not very NICE things I might add. St. Paul City Councilman David Thune has a nasty mouth when it comes to his constitiuents. Sheldon Johnson (incumbent) is running against David Carlson in district 67B (East side of St. Paul), and has been up to some nasty tricks. I have attached the police report Dave filed, along with evidence of letters/e-mails sent to David Carlson. I have also heard that Sheldon Johnson is working out of his capital office for his campaign...I thought that was illegal? Well, I might just have to follow up on that for my parents....they are in his district. I'll let you know what I find out.






St. Paul city councilman sends profane email from city account

A profanity laced email from a St. Paul city councilman is leading to calls for his resignation.
St. Paul businessman, Mike Costello said he got upset last week when he saw City Councilman David Thune protesting at the Republican National Convention.
"I sent him an email saying how disgusted I was and that I thought he was a disgrace to the city and I asked him for his resignation. I said you should resign," said Costello.
Thune responded with an email that said "[expletive] you little [expletive]".
5 EYEWITNESS NEWS obtained a copy of the profanity-filled email which shows it was sent from Thune's official city council email address.
When asked if that was a respectful way to deal with a citizen of St. Paul Thune said, "It is a respectful way to deal with someone of the low class that he is."
"It was vulgar. It was crude and it was sent from his city desk," said Costello.
Thune told 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS he stands behind his four-letter words, even though he said he never really meant to sent the email.
"I was shocked. I can't believe he sent it," said Costello.
City officials said there is little that can be done to punish and elected official such as Thune for using city property to verbally attack a citizen.
5 EYEWITNESS NEWS asked Mayor Coleman's office what he thinks of the situation. They issued no comment.
Costello said he has filed a formal complaint with the city.
If you prefer to watch & listen to the KSTP video, click the link below.

http://kstp.com:80/article/stories/S575598.shtml

Monday, September 22, 2008

10,000 "page views" for FreedomToAct.com. Thank you loyal readers.

Redrant:   First off, the website traffic is steady, the interest in altering the smoking ban is still strong.  I haven't checked the traffic data in a while but this seems to be the key site for this effort.  I strongly encourage you to regularly visit http://freedomfight08.com/ which is the same as http://banthebanminnesota.com  The latter domain name is meant to coordinate with the Wisconsin effort.  Whatever you can remember.  Sean has been working very hard at this and he deserves more traffic for his fine website so spread the word.  

Sean put a lot of effort into a "legislative scorecard". http://banthebanminnesota.com/government_scorecard.aspx  Check it out.  First off, vote in the upcoming election, it matters.    Next  consider financial aid to those candidates who are up for reelection and support our side.  This can be done with the Minnesota $50/$100 single, married couple refundable campaign donation.  Charity begins at home so try to find a supportive candidate in your area.  There are some criteria but the candidate has to disclose their eligibility.  Google them, email them and ask their position on the limited bar smoking exemption and their eligibility for the rebate.  Most are and will proudly state this.  If you send in a check note "$50/100 MN refund" on check and include a note stating that the donation is for the MN $50/100 refundable.  Basically a technicality but if they aren't they are legally obligated to return the check.  

Also, keep in mind that the MN state computer does a cross check for back obligations like child support, unpaid taxes or fines but you should know about these.  If your clean you should receive a full refund in under 60 days.  I opted for direct deposit where I received a $50 direct deposit in three weeks (I was watching for a substantially larger property tax refund so when I saw the $50 deposit I "had a cow" but soon figured it out (the state of MN does not describe these well).  I have since received my full property tax refund direct deposit.  Let's say it was closer to four figure than three.  I didn't realise that I was eligible for the refund the previous year (deadline for filing for previous year 08-15-2008).  When I searched a few days back I found I missed the deadline on a $500+ refund)  Check out to see if you are eligible.  Do the research.   I'm sure all readers could use the money.  It's called the "circuit breaker".  Mention it to people to see if they are eligible.  
http://www.taxes.state.mn.us/prop_refund/forms.shtml

With higher fuel costs everyone loves money so check out the renters/property owners refunds.